Saturday, November 28, 2020
ABORTION Planned Parenthood Loses Key Court Battle

Planned Parenthood Loses Key Court Battle

Like the post? Why not make it Facebook official. ⇊

Abortion mill Planned Parenthood lost a key federal court case on Friday which, according to one major newspaper, means the organization is now a “step closer” to being defunded, in Texas at least.


General Michael Flynn defense fund Fellow patriots, please listen to this short, inspiring message from General Flynn. General Michael Flynn exemplifies patriotism, courage, and love of God and country - despite some of his own countrymen relentlessly attacking him. Donations for his defense are greatly appreciated. If you can only give $5.00, please do so - every little bit helps. Thank you so much, and God bless. Letter from General Flynn. 

Almost two years ago, U.S. District Judge Sam Sparks issued a preliminary injunction against the state, which prevented it from withholding funds from Planned Parenthood following the release of bombshell undercover videos showing representatives of the abortion provider discussing the for-profit sale of aborted fetuses.

However, on Thursday the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th District in New Orleans ruled that Judge Sparks didn’t use the correct review standard, so the three-judge panel vacated his 2017 injunction and remanded the case back to his court in Austin, the Washington Post reported.

Crucially, the 5th Circuit ordered that Texas’ decision to defund Planned Parenthood “may only be overturned if it fails to satisfy ‘minimum standards of rationality,’” according to The Associated Press.

Additionally, the appeals court was critical of Sparks for questioning the genuineness of the undercover video from the pro-life group Center for American Progress. The higher court pointed out in its decision that the “district court stated, inaccurately, that the CMP video had not been authenticated and suggested it may have been edited.”

In a footnote attached to the quote, the appeals court noted further that “the record reflects that [The Office of Inspector General] had submitted a report from a forensic firm concluding that the video was authentic and not deceptively edited. And the plaintiffs did not identify any particular omission or addition in the video footage.”

You Might Like

Further, the footnote added that “the district court also suggested that there was no evidence that any of [Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast]’s research was federally funded, so the regulations relied on by OIG might be inapplicable. But the record actually establishes that the [University of Texas Medical Branch in Galveston] study was funded by the National Institute of Health.”

Seth Chandler, a law professor at the University of Houston, told the Post that the appeals court ruling is a big problem for Planned Parenthood because Sparks will now have to determine, if he once again rules against Texas, whether the state was “arbitrary and capricious” in deciding to defund the abortion provider.

“I think it’s going to be quite difficult for Planned Parenthood to prevail,” Chandler told the Post.

“The standard the 5th Circuit has set down is one that, given the evidence and the history in this case, and a clear signal from the 5th Circuit in this case, Planned Parenthood is going to be hard-pressed to meet.

“The $3.4 million Planned Parenthood receives from Texas pursuant to the Medicaid program is very likely going to go away,” he said.

The Post added:

Even if Sparks again rules for Planned Parenthood, Chandler said it’s clear from [Judge Edith H.] Jones’ ruling that the 5th Circuit isn’t inclined to do any favors for the health-care provider. Jones, in particular, has openly criticized the Supreme Court’s decision in Roe v. Wade. In this ruling, she included a graphic photo of bloody fetal tissue that came from the video footage, apparently for dramatic effect, Chandler said.

“There are some signs of hostility to abortion in that opinion,” he added to the paper, “and the 5th Circuit has pretty strongly hinted how it’s going to come out.”

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton noted after the 5th Circuit’s ruling that “Planned Parenthood’s reprehensible conduct, captured in undercover videos, proves that it is not a ‘qualified’ provider under the Medicaid Act, so we are confident we will ultimately prevail.”

Republished with permission The National Sentinel


Viewpoints expressed herein are of the article’s author(s), or of the person(s) or organization(s) quoted or linked therein, and do not necessarily represent those of TCP News

What you can do to help:


It is vitally important that we all take the time to like and share articles regardless of what site you are on. Conservative sites (like this one) cannot count on traffic from Facebook etc. any more. Subscribing is also important; this bypasses the censorship. The more that we can get the word out the better – and in order to continue bringing you content like this – we ALL need traffic in order to survive. Running a website is not only expensive, it also takes a lot of time and effort.

No one likes ads, but very few people will donate, hence the reason most of us have ads.

Besides donating and clicking on ads, you can make a purchase from our store and buy my book.

Don't forget to follow TCP News on Parler, USA Life, Gab, Facebook, and Twitter

TCP News is proud to be ranked #24 in the Top 40 Conservative Political Blogs

Thank you for helping us grow, we appreciate it!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related news

State Rep. Mark Baisley: NO One Has the Constitutional Authority to Restrict Thanksgiving Family Gatherings

Democrats Don’t Have the Constitutional Authority to Impose Thanksgiving Restrictions.   By Rusty Weiss A state representative in Colorado is reminding Americans that no lawmaker has the “constitutional authority”...

Take Time to Give Thanks – to the Lord

As we celebrate Thanksgiving this year, let us be reminded in our hearts to give thanks to our God. By Greg Holt Our Father who art...

Headline News 11/26/2020

Good morning, we aim to start your day off right with relevant headline news that’s happening around the world, not to mention our own timely...

2020 Election Showed Limits of Criminal Justice Reform

In the wake of riots and out of control crime, voters are concerned and want law and order, even in liberal areas.   By Jeff Crouere In...